Phase

Is quitting vaping harder than quitting smoking?

No study has compared the two head to head, so nobody can give you an honest yes or no. The nicotine and the withdrawal are the same, and the CDC says quitting vaping is likely similar to quitting smoking (CDC). What differs is the habit. A vape is always within reach, never burns down, and some pods deliver nicotine as fast as a cigarette.

Below, each difference and how strong its evidence is. Much of it comes from people who quit cigarettes, and we say so each time. This is general information, not medical advice.

Quitting vaping vs smoking: the short comparison

CigarettesVapesHow sure we are
The drugNicotineNicotineCertain
WithdrawalIrritability, anxiety, poor focus, poor sleep; eases over 2 to 4 weeks (Hughes, 2007)The same nicotine withdrawal (Smokefree.gov)Timing measured in people who quit cigarettes
Speed of the hitFastPod devices can match a cigarette (Hajek et al., 2020)One small lab study
Natural stopping pointThe cigarette endsNonePlain design fact
Measured dependenceHigherLower in older surveys (Shiffman and Sembower, 2020)Data from before pods were common
Proven quit medicinesSeveral (CDC)None approved for vaping (Smokefree.gov)Certain

Vape withdrawal vs cigarette withdrawal: is one worse?

Nicotine is nicotine, whether it comes from smoke or aerosol. Smokefree.gov, run by the US National Cancer Institute, says most vapes contain nicotine, so you may get nicotine withdrawal symptoms when you quit, and that "the worst withdrawal symptoms only last a few days to a couple of weeks" (Smokefree.gov).

The detailed timeline comes from cigarettes. A review of withdrawal research found that anger, anxiety, difficulty concentrating, impatience, insomnia and restlessness peak within the first week and last two to four weeks (Hughes, 2007). A brain-imaging study in people who quit cigarettes found that nicotine receptors stayed raised for up to a month and returned to normal levels by 6 to 12 weeks (Cosgrove et al., 2009).

No published study has measured vape withdrawal against cigarette withdrawal this way. If anyone says one is worse, ask for the study. Expect similar symptoms on a similar clock, scaled to how much nicotine you took in.

Why is vaping so hard to quit?

If withdrawal is similar, the difference is in how the habit is built.

No natural end

A cigarette burns down, and the session is over. A vape has no such limit. You can take one puff or forty, and nothing tells you to stop. A University of Kentucky nursing researcher put it this way: the ease and discreetness of vaping can "promote frequent use and expose the user to higher sustained levels of nicotine when compared to lighting/relighting cigarettes" (UKNow, 2019). That's an expert view, not a measurement.

Always within reach

You can't smoke at your desk, in bed or on a train, so smoking comes with built-in breaks. A vape fits in your pocket and leaves little smell, so those breaks disappear. Availability matters when you quit. In a study of people quitting cigarettes who reported their urges in real time, first slips were more likely when cigarettes were easy to get, when others were smoking, and when mood was low (Shiffman et al., 1996). That was about cigarettes, but a device that never leaves your pocket is about as available as nicotine gets.

Nicotine salts and stronger pods

Many pods and disposables use nicotine salts. An acid added to the liquid makes high-strength nicotine smoother to inhale. In a randomised trial, 119 adults rated salt liquids as smoother, less harsh and more appealing than the same strength without the acid (Leventhal et al., 2021).

Smoother means you can take in more nicotine without coughing. In a lab study with 20 people who both smoked and vaped, a US Juul pod (59 mg/mL of nicotine) raised blood nicotine about as high and as fast as a cigarette, and faster than eight other vapes (Hajek et al., 2020). The authors note that the US version has more nicotine than the one sold in Europe. In the UK, e-liquids are limited to 20 mg/mL (GOV.UK).

Hard to count

A pack is its own counter. Puffs leave no trace, so it's hard to notice a habit growing, and harder to cut down on purpose. The cheapest fix is to count your puffs for a few ordinary days before you change anything. Our guide to how many puffs a day explains how.

Where quitting vaping may be easier

The evidence doesn't all point one way.

Measured dependence has been lower. In a US survey of 13,311 adults, people scored lower on a dependence scale for e-cigarettes than for cigarettes, including people who used both (Shiffman and Sembower, 2020). An earlier survey reached a similar conclusion (Etter and Eissenberg, 2015). The catch: the US data were collected from 2013 to 2016. By early 2019, Juul alone held about three-quarters of the US e-cigarette market (Truth Initiative). Today's high-strength pods may tell a different story, and nobody has published that comparison yet.

You can step down in small, exact steps. Pods come in strengths, and puffs can be counted and cut one day at a time. The NHS says that "cutting down on nicotine vaping gradually can make quitting easier" (NHS). Our step-by-step taper turns that into a schedule.

Persistence isn't the same as difficulty. In a UK trial, people who quit cigarettes with an e-cigarette were far more likely to still use it at one year than people who quit with nicotine replacement: 80% against 9% (Hajek et al., 2019). That's often quoted as proof vaping is harder to quit. But those people weren't trying to stop vaping. It shows that people keep vaping, not that they fail when they try.

What the evidence doesn't tell you yet

There's one area where quitting vaping is clearly harder: there are fewer proven tools. The FDA has approved seven medicines to help people quit smoking (CDC). None is approved for quitting vaping (Smokefree.gov).

A 2025 Cochrane review found 15 trials of ways to quit vaping. It found low-certainty evidence that varenicline, a prescription medicine, may help, and inconclusive evidence for nicotine replacement (Butler et al., 2025). If you want medicine or nicotine replacement, a pharmacist or clinician can help you choose.

So the honest answer has three parts. The withdrawal is probably about the same. The habit is often more constant. And the tested help is thinner. Your plan should target the habit, not just the nicotine.

How to quit vaping when the habit is the hard part

  1. Count before you cut. A few ordinary days of counting gives you a real starting number.
  2. Put limits back in. Pick a daily puff budget that falls to zero by your quit day, or set a firm quit date and stop. Our guide to cold turkey or stepping down helps you choose.
  3. Rebuild the breaks. Keep the vape out of your pocket, out of your bed and out of the car. Make each puff a decision.
  4. Plan for the slip. If it happens, it's a lapse, not the end. Read what to do after one puff.
  5. Don't swap back to cigarettes. If you vaped to quit smoking, the NHS says going back to vaping is much better than starting to smoke again (NHS).

Phase is built for the counting problem: it counts puffs from widgets, Control Center or Siri, and sets a daily budget that falls to zero on your quit day. Whatever you use, start with our full plan to quit vaping.

Questions

Is vaping more addictive than smoking?

Surveys from before high-strength pods were common found lower dependence on e-cigarettes than on cigarettes. Some newer pods can deliver nicotine about as fast as a cigarette, so that gap may have narrowed. No recent study settles it.

Is vape withdrawal worse than cigarette withdrawal?

There's no direct comparison. Both are nicotine withdrawal, with the same symptoms, and Smokefree.gov says the worst of it lasts a few days to a couple of weeks. How hard it feels depends more on how much nicotine you were using than on the device.

Why is vaping so hard to quit?

The nicotine is only part of it. A vape has no natural end, is always within reach, and is easy to use without counting. That builds a habit with few breaks.

Is it harder to quit vaping if you vaped to quit smoking?

In one large US survey, the highest e-cigarette dependence scores were among people who vaped and had stopped smoking. If that's you, plan for the habit carefully, and make sure a slip doesn't send you back to cigarettes.

Sources

Your count starts the moment you open Phase.

Download on the App Store

SOS breathing works without Pro. Phase Pro costs $19.99 a year after a 7-day free trial, $5.99 a month, or $39.99 once (US prices).